Benneckenstein to the World of Carnivores
The world of carnivorous plants is the world of
Siegfried and Irmgard Hartmeyer. The couple has traveled to the remotest
regions with their camera equipment, mostly tracking those plant genera which
evolution has endowed with a special appetite for animal protein.
A fleeting encounter almost 45 years ago with a
round-leaved sundew and a Venus flytrap has become a lifelong passion. Today,
the Hartmeyers are networked worldwide with carnivorous plant specialists and experiment not
only in their own greenhouse with microscopes, tweezers and cameras. Because of
their private films and research results, they have been invited to give video
lectures for instance to groups of prominent scientists in Japan and the USA.
In addition, there were joint research projects
and scientific publications. For example, they have done work with the bionics scientists
of the University of Freiburg, where investigations with a high-speed camera
and electron microscope described a new type of trap. This was the rapid
catapult-flypaper trap that disproved the myth all prey capture movements in Drosera are rather slow. If this was not
enough, one sundew discovered by them in Australia even bears their name: Drosera
readers will probably be familiar with these carnivorous specialists because of
several reports. To all other readers, today's interview should be preceded by
a short personal note.
Hartmeyer was born in Hasselfelde in 1953 because the planned home birth in
Benneckenstein's Unterbruch 1 had to be moved to the hospital there at short
notice - the Midwife had fled to the West of Germany overnight. He spent the
first years of his childhood in Benneckenstein, before the unlawful
expropriation of the Hartmeyer family business that forced his parents to leave
home for West Germany. Professionally, things went well for him as a laboratory
groups director and plant fireman in the gas measuring group in the analytics
department of a Swiss chemical company. Despite all his geographical
remoteness, Siegfried Hartmeyer always remained connected with the Harz region.
From the mid-1960s until today, kinship ties have led to many visits to the old
homeland and ultimately to the circle of the Benneckenstein Culture and
Heritage Society. Also the collaboration on the biographical book of his mother
Christa Hartmeyer "Gezeitenwechsel im Hochharz" (translated “Changing
Tides in the Upper Harz Mountains”) provided a strong connection. Today we want
to ask him what special features he has encountered in his greenhouse over the
Photo: Christa Hartmeyer with her book "Gezeitenwechsel im Hochharz" (Photo supplemented).
Hartmeyer, what actually fascinates you so much about carnivorous plants, which
you also like to call "Fleischis"?
And: Do you have any favorites
among the nearly 1,000 known species?
I am particularly interested in the highly effective
animal traps of carnivorous plants, which give botanists and others the
impression of ingenious evolutionary engineering, that is the biomechanics, or
bionics for short. For example at the University of Freiburg studies snapping, catapulting
or sucking carnivorous plant traps with latest analytical equipment, engineers
are already transforming these into advanced and environmentally friendly
practical applications. Studies of the mechanism of the Venus flytrap Dionaea
muscipula, helped in the development of autonomously opening and closing
sunshade lamellas for the shading of buildings and stadiums. They are operated
without hinges, electricity or motors, using the mechanisms of the famous snap
traps, the targeted use of inner tensions of the material. When you see such
successes of bionics in practice, it is only then that one really understands
what fascinating mechanisms evolution has produced with the carnivore traps.
my favorites among carnivores are the fast catapult traps of some sundews, especially
the the largest, Drosera glanduligera, in which our research played a
major role. It caused a lot of headaches. The plant was still considered
uncultivable in the early 2000s and it took us almost three years before we
were able to obtain reproducibly healthy adult plants for our experiments. The
truly sensational results show that the catapults of this sundew move at least
as fast as the Venus flytrap does.
article we published among others in the U.S. in 2010, was read by the bionics
team at the University of Freiburg, and probably because we were the only ones
who could provide healthy experimental plants, the current head of the Plant
Biomechanics Group, Dr. Simon Poppinga, invited us to join a joint research
project. In order to be allowed to experiment in the strictly secured
laboratories, Irmgard and I first had to sign 16 (!) declarations of secrecy.
The result of the following, very friendly cooperation was a publication in
2012 describing a new type of trapping, a combined catapult-flypaper trap. In
experiments, it hurls passing fruit flies with outstretched catapults (snap
tentacles) lying on the ground in sensational 75 thousandths of a second (ms)
onto their leaves, which have hairs covered with glue. This is much faster than
Dionaea which needs 100 ms for closing. The impact of the fly on the
leaf starts a kind of belt conveyor mechanism in the glue tentacles of the leaf
surface, which sinks the prey into a digestive cavity in one to two minutes, a
kind of stomach sack in the center of the leaf.
Even the well-known German science journalist Volker
Arzt asked by e-mail whether he could show the pictures of the fly-slinging
predatory plant, taken in our living room, for the first time on television in
the program "Planet Wissen". Of course, we gladly agreed. The report
was broadcast in 2015 and online until the end of 2020.
Photo: The Australian catapult-flypaper trap Drosera glanduligera flings passing animals into its glue tentacles in just 75 thousandths of a second (ms).
In the Guinness World Records 2021, it is now listed as "fastest terrestrial predatory plant".
when were carnivores actually described scientifically?
Carnivorous plants were first scientifically described
in the 18th century, not infrequently by the famous Carl von Linné, the
inventor of binary nomenclature, with the help of which science can name all
living beings by means of a genus and species name. However, even at that time,
he generally rejected the assumption that these plants were carnivorous, i.e.
they deliberately ate animals. He probably feared trouble from religious
authorities for such claims, similar to those experienced 100 years later by
Charles Darwin for suggesting carnivorous plants.
For Darwin this criticism was
not less massive than for his theory of evolution published 16 years
before. In 1875 Darwin published his famous experiments with sundew, etc. the
first scientific book, "Insectivorous Plants" in which, as the title
suggests, he clearly writes about insectivorous plants. Evangelical fanatics
saw the "divine order" endangered if plants were to eat animals
instead of the other way around.
Today, it is scientifically undisputed that
carnivores capture insects and digest them with enzymes, so Darwin was right.
We were even able to clearly prove in experiments that some sundew species
already starve to death as seedlings if they cannot catch enough food.
Left photo: Drosera aberrans „Maldon“ is a winter grower and stands the hot Australian summers dormant as a tuber, similar to our crocuses.
Right photo: Drosera capensis x aliciae
a beautiful hybrid from two South African species. After about 38
years, it is meanwhile the oldest sundew of the Hartmeyer collection.
does one get an invitation to Japan, for example, with such a hobby?
For the answer I must go a little further. Irmgard and
I spent since 1990 on three carefully prepared trips totaling of more than
seven months in Australia, where most species of carnivorous plants exist. The
motto for us was always "Take only photos, leave only footprints".
With small airplanes, helicopters and cross-country vehicles we searched and
filmed carnivores and a phenomena associated with them, sometimes accompanied
by local experts, but mostly as a team of two. We observed symbioses between
carnivorous plants and predatory bugs (Cyrtopeltis & Bybliphilus),
which can live completely unharmed and mutually beneficial in the midst of the
glue traps . In "Down Under", until our publication in an Australian
journal in 1996, such symbioses/mutualisms were only known from a rather
limited region about 3000 km south around the city of Perth.
In addition to our private investments in adventurous
excursions and better film equipment we had a good portion of luck. Irmgard and
I actually managed to film several undescribed symbiosis/mutualisms in northern
Australia. As the icing on the cake, we found an undescribed sundew in 1995,
whose transformed "tentacles" (emergences) reflect yellow light.
This was new in the genus Drosera.
after this plant suddenly appeared in Germany, we showed it to the
and systematist Dr. Jan Schlauer, who was really electrified by our
find and immediately
started the scientific description of the new species. The reflective
emergences of "our" sundew and the newly found symbioses caused a
worldwide attention in expert circles. Nevertheless, I was astonished
suddenly the letter of a Prof. Kondo from Hiroshima University arrived
words: "I would like to invite you to show a film lecture about your
discoveries in Australia in the context of the International
Conference 2002 at the Natural History Museum in Tokyo. In addition, I
pleased if you could produce an official video about the
conference." This was such a great honor for us that we
booked the flights. The conference in English was a great success,
brought us many new worldwide contacts, friendships and follow-up
Photo: The yellow light reflecting emergences (magnified on the right) of Drosera hartmeyerorum
lure insects into the deadly glue traps. This is only known from this species.
you also experienced bizarre surprises in the greenhouse?
Oh yes, our mouse-eating pitcher plants Nepenthes
come to mind. Small vertebrates have been found in large pitchers in Borneo,
but it was surprising in our greenhouse. A total of five mice were caught by
two large plants in a few years, so this was not a one-time fluke. We would
never feed vertebrates to plants!
The mice came in unwanted, and we always
noticed it only by the typical stench near the trap, when digestion had already
started. In fact, the pitchers function like a real stomach with digestive
enzymes. For us of course it was an ideal opportunity to investigate how the plant
does this and what remains from such large prey.
The following probably took place: Attracted by the
sugar-containing excretions, which are produced by the nectar glands on the
underside of the lid, the mouse climbs up the rough outer surface of the pitcher
onto the sturdy "collar", the peristome, which surrounds the opening.
There it must stand up on two legs and bend slightly forward to lick the sweet
drops under the lid above her. Thereby a careless movement is enough, the rest
is done by gravity. The victim falls into the digestive fluid and drowns
without any chance of climbing the very smooth inner walls. Since all pitchers
remained completely undamaged after the capture, it was a proof that there was
no possibility for the rodents to bite through the walls.
The digestion of an adult mouse takes about six weeks.
When the trap was cut open, the remains were completely flattened and seemed
almost grown into the wall. So robust is the lower part of the pitcher that it
needed to be cut with a scalpel to remove the remains. Remaining were the fur,
hairs and gnawing teeth, as well as small remains of the most massive bones.
The rest of the body had been digested with enzymes and absorbed. The latter
could be seen by the fact that the following pitchers of the plant grew even
larger and stronger. As macabre as the pictures may be, our somewhat bizarre
article with the photos found great interest. Translations appeared in several countries;
even a large Indonesian garden magazine (Trubus) printed a report on it.
Upper left photo: As if the little mouth was still open in horror even in death.
The photo of this mouse caught in the trap of a Philippine Nepenthes truncata went around the world.
Upper right photo: The pitcher plant with two teeth,
Nepenthes bicalcarata from Borneo lives in symbiosis with ants
(Camponotus schmitzii), which hunt for prey by diving in the pitcher liquid. Smooth pitcher walls do not bother them.
Left photo: The sharp little teeth of this Nepenthes hamata from Sulawesi effectively prevent animals that have fallen into the pitcher from escaping.
Less bizarre, even dangerous turned out to be captures
in the greenhouse of the tropical tiger mosquito Aedes aegypti, which
immigrated only a few years ago, and which we discovered in the glue of our
sundews. They transmit dangerous diseases such as Zika, Chikungunya and dengue
fever. The Weiler Public Order Office had asked citizens to report findings of
the mosquitoes. They immediately sent a biologist to us, who confirmed that
they were indeed the tropical bloodsuckers. He gave me Culinex tablets,
with Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis with which the old branches of the Upper Rhine Valley are
treated every spring. It is only deadly for mosquito larvae. One hundred years
ago, our region was still a malaria area due to its mild climate and the transmitting
Anopheles mosquitoes are still present. A broth from the tablets is then
given into the water bowls in which our carnivores are standing, which are
unfortunately also ideal breeding sites for the invasive tiger mosquitoes. The
control is supported by our numerous sundew species in the greenhouse, for
which all the mosquitoes are ideal prey.
Photo: Hunting for dangerous tiger mosquitoes Aedes aegyptii, these Drosera serpens (left) and Drosera paradoxa
(both Australia) were successful in the greenhouse. This also helped to clearly identify the mosquitoes.
you still currently involved in scientific projects on carnivorous plants?
This hobby has never been and will never be boring.
Since 2016 we have been cultivating certain sundew species in order to examine
them for their chemical constituents in collaboration with Dr. Jan Schlauer.
The so-called chemotaxonomy is quite helpful for both systematics and questions
about the evolution of the genus. Up to 2019, this resulted in several
scientific publications. All these articles can be found on our homepage.
Only last year, together with Prof. Stephen Williams
(USA), we were able to publish an article about experiments with ants in our
garden, which happened to have made a burrow right next to a group of Venus
flytraps and really walked permanently through the traps without triggering
them - A great coincidence. We succeeded in proving statistically that the
large snap traps allow small ants, which are unprofitable as prey, to escape in
a targeted manner by combining several ingenious features in order to save
energy. Of course, we have films of this, which can be seen on our YouTube
channel. In the meantime, more than 1.6 million views prove that they are of
But one more point on your question: Fortunately - you
will have guessed it - even during this interview, some laboratory equipment
runs analyzing our plant samples taken in 2020. Sown in April, we harvested
them at the beginning of October in the greenhouse and sent them by express to
a laboratory in Helsinki. It looks quite good so far; a new publication will be
released in 2021 at the latest, depending on the duration of the peer reviews it
will appear in a specialist journal.
Recently, we were surprised to receive an e-mail from
Dr. Poppinga from the University of Freiburg with great news: The
aforementioned catapult-flypaper trap has now been entered into the Guinness
Book of Records as the "fastest terrestrial predatory plant in the
world" with 75 thousandths of a second (ms) for a capture process, based
on our joint laboratory measurements.
(Photo supplemented: A happy celebration with
Guinness. The upper portraits show the Australian Richard Davion
(left), who found the catapult function and Dr Simon Poppinga, who
conducted the speed measurements together with the Hartmeyers at the
University of Freiburg (Germany).
years ago you combined a vacation in the Harz mountains with some excursions
through our Brocken moors. Accompanied by Brocken gardener Dr. Gunter Karste,
you were able to examine the sundew deposits there. You published your results
in a very interesting and not less entertaining video. Is there perhaps the
intention to repeat such an action again?
I have the best memories of the excursions with Dr.
Gunter Karste on the Brocken and surroundings. We saw, for the first time
butterworts (Pinguicula), sundew as well as some orchids (Dactylorhiza
species) at natural places in my old homeland. This was a great experience,
especially because the fascination for carnivorous plants in me was actually
caused by the round-leaved sundew D. rotundifolia.
I am still happy like crazy when I see this plant in
the nature in front of my camera. In addition there is also scientific
interest. As the only one of our native sundew species, D. rotundifolia
forms at different times either glue tentacles or completely dry snap
tentacles, similar to the ones of the Australian catapult traps, although not
quite as fast moving. Why there is this dimorphism here and what causes the
formation of the different tentacles in this species, I have not yet been able
to explain. I hope that it will happen one day. Our film “Fleischfresser auf
dem Blocksberg” (Translated "Carnivores on the Blocksberg"), which
also deals with our family history in Benneckenstein, can be watched free of
charge on our YouTube channel.
We have considered further excursions in the Brocken
area a few times since then. At the moment, however, we can't travel with my
89-year-old mother, who of course always accompanied us to Benneckenstein. For
health reasons we do not want to leave her alone for a long period in Corona
times. I am sure that we will go on tour in the Harz mountains again in the
future and we are looking forward to it!
Photo:Siggi and Irmgard Hartmeyer in their impressive
greenhouse full of hungry plant stomachs.
Jürgen Kohlrausch thanks you for the interview.